Review of
Charlotte Bronte before Jane Eyre,
by Glynnis Fawkes ISBN 9781368023290
Five out of five stars
Excellent biography in graphic novel form
I have long
been a proponent of education in whatever form it takes. Whether it be in textual,
comic book or in the form of a graphic novel. In this book the graphic novel
form is used to describe the life of Charlotte Bronte before she became a
published novelist. It is very well done.
Not only does
it portray the struggles of families due to regular deaths from disease and
other ailments, the economic plight of women in the early nineteenth century is
described. Charlotte’s father recognized that his daughters needed to be
educated and he did what he could, sending them off to school. However, even
with education, jobs such as being a teacher/governess were fraught with
problems. The children often did not have the slightest interest in learning,
only in being difficult. All three of the Bronte sisters were writers and
initially started out with poetry, using aliases so that readers would not know
that they were female.
While the
dialog is not verbatim concerning what the Bronte girls said, it has to be very
close. The tone is that of a nineteenth century young woman and they sound very
much like their writings. One of the best attributes of a biography is that
when dialog attributed to the subject is not being quoted, it sounds like them.
In other words, they could have said it.
This is one of
the most educational graphic novels I have ever encountered. It captures the
life and struggles of nineteenth century women in general and Charlotte Bronte
in particular.