Review of
The Great Quarterback Switch,
by Matt Christopher, ISBN 0316140775
Three out of five stars
More fiction than the usual sports fiction book
Michael and Tom
Curtis are identical twins and both love football. Tom is an athlete and the
quarterback of the Eagles football team. Due to an accident, Michael is
confined to a wheelchair, so he is limited to watching and yelling
encouragement.
However, they
have an adult friend named Ollie Pruitt that believes that believes in transmigration
of bodies and personalities. It turns out that if both boys wish it very hard,
their bodies can be interchanged to the extent that Michael becomes the ambulatory
one while Tom is the one confided to a wheelchair.
This trick is
used to give Tom respites in the games, for when he gets tired or banged up
Michael can go in for him. It works very well, for Michael has memorized all
the plays, has an excellent understanding of football and is also athletic.
The season
moves forward and there are a couple of girls that go out of their way to
interact with Michael and Tom. Unlike many other adolescent sports fiction,
there is no dramatic last second win at the end, which is positive, for such
things rarely happen.
If it were not
for the fantasy aspects of partial physical transmigration, this would have
been a good story. The only characteristic that is swapped between the two boys
is the ability to be ambulatory. Other than that, their bodies swap. Which is
more along the line of magic rather than fantasy.
No comments:
Post a Comment