Review of
Hiroshima:
Why the Bomb Was Dropped, narrated by Peter Jennings DVD
version
Five out of five stars
Fifty years
after the atomic bombs were dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, it was still
difficult for there to be an impartial description of the context and
consequences of the American dropping of the two nuclear weapons on what were
essentially defenseless Japanese cities. As Jennings reports, when the
Smithsonian Museum was developing an exhibit describing the bombings, some
groups so strongly objected to the images of injured Japanese civilians that the
museum felt forced to drop that feature and scale the exhibit down so that all
that remained was the plane that delivered the first bomb to Hiroshima.
Given the
momentous nature of the decision to use nuclear weapons, the viewer will be surprised
at how little debate there was over their use and how detached President Harry
Truman was from the discussions. It truly was as if only the scientists
understood the tremendous power of the weapons and the extensive destruction
and loss of life there would be. It was truly an Earth-shattering event.
Much of the
context of the times has been lost to history, so modern observers generally
cannot place themselves in the public mood after the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor.
The American military and public were aware of the high casualty numbers in the
battle for the Japanese island of Okinawa and there was no reason to believe
that any battle over the main Japanese islands would not be worse. Therefore,
it can be argued that the use of the atomic weapons did in fact save lives,
although it will not be conclusive, for it was possible that Japan could have
suddenly surrendered. There is no evidence to support the oft-cited figure of
one million American casualties if they were to invade the Japanese main
islands.
Peter Jennings
and ABC news does an excellent job in doing a deep dive into the historical
context of Harry Truman and how short a time he had in office when he had to
make the decision to drop the atomic bombs. There were strong personalities
around him that advocated their use with few and rather tepid statements of
opposition.