Review of
Instaread Summary, Analysis & Review of Glenn Beck's Liars How Progressives Exploit
Our Fear for Power and Control
Four out of five stars
There are
people on the right that loudly proclaim their repeated message that those on
the left are always wrong and have a dark agenda for taking control of the
United States. Similarly, there are those on the left that say the same things
about those on the right. In both cases their tactics are to engage in extreme
rhetoric, taking a few examples and amplifying them beyond their applicability.
Glenn Beck has long been such a person on the right side of the American political
spectrum. The inclusion of the word “liars” in the title to describe
progressives demonstrates his use of extreme rhetoric.
Like so many
conservatives, Beck opens with a historical falsehood based on the American
constitution. It appears in key takeaway one.
“The United States was founded on principles of
individual liberty and limited government, but in the nineteenth century, the
country found itself being influenced by the tenets of socialism and communism
that had been sweeping across Europe, where the failed revolutions of 1848 set
the stage for a new era of class warfare.”
All true
students of American history know that the United States was founded on the
principles of individual liberty, but only for landed white males. Slavery and
considering Native Americans and women to be second-class or non-citizens were
fundamental components of the founding of the nation. It was progressives that
led the battle to end slavery, giving women equal rights to men and Native
Americans the opportunity to avoid being exterminated. The American Civil War
had nothing to do with class warfare.
Beck also
demonstrates a lack of understanding regarding the European revolutions of
1848. They were largely about eliminating the power of the aristocracy and
transferring more power to the people. In other words, the freedom and
democracy that Beck claims to champion.
I have no doubt
that this summary is an accurate rendition of what is in the book. Glenn Beck
has been saying the same things for many years and this is just a retread of
those thoughts and opinions. Updated to reflect the players in the 2016
presidential election, but other than that there is nothing new stated in this
summary and almost certainly also in the book. There is no critical analysis in
the summary, hence the four stars.
No comments:
Post a Comment