Review of
The Great War WWI,
Timeless Media Group
Four out of five stars
Too much repetitive video out of context
The origins of
the First World War were both simple and complex. They were simple in that
there was a system of alliances that counterbalanced each other and there was
an arms race, specifically at sea between Great Britain and Germany. This
created a natural rivalry between the two groups, where no nation was secure
enough to not support the nations allied with it. It was complex in that the alliances
were not as rigid as all sides felt they were.
This set of
DVDs starts with the origins of the war and does a reasonable job in explaining
how the war started. It also points out that few if any people on either side
had any idea that the war would be as destructive as it turned out to be.
In the middle,
the description of the conflict is very nonlinear and repeats the same video
loops over and over again. Sometimes, the video does not match what is being
described. At times the movement from one video to the other is logically and
temporally inconsistent.
The examination
of the war ends with the rather abrupt end and the political and social
aftermath. One unusual treatment is that of the Allied involvement in the Siberian
area of the emerging Soviet Union after the collapse of the Russian Empire. This
is an area of history not often covered. Few people in the United States know
that a significant number of American troops were in what is now Russia after
the German surrender.
While this is
not a high tier video description of the First World War, it is still good
enough to be part of the education of modern students in this brutal conflict
that was a war beyond anything anyone thought possible.
No comments:
Post a Comment