Review of
Aftermath:
Following the Bloodshed of America’s Wars in the Muslim World, by Bir Rosen, ISBN 9781568584010
Five out
of five stars
Depressing,
yet illuminating story of the misguided wars
In the aftermath of the United States engaging
in acts of war against the Iranian nation, reading this book is extremely
important. Those of us that follow these things remember how the administration
of George W. Bush justified their invasion of Iraq on massive falsehoods
regarding terrorism, supposed weapons of mass destruction and the vague concept
of bringing freedom and democracy to the Arab nations.
Rosen does a superb job in explaining how the
invasion of Iraq simply split open all of the underlying hostilities between
the Sunni and Shiite populations of Iraq as well as the aspirations of the
Kurds for their own nation. Rosen begins with a historical recapitulation of
the religious differences between the Sunni and Shiite branches of Islam. The mechanisms
whereby the British Empire carved Iraq out of the remains of the Ottoman Empire
are also explained along with how this created ethnic conflicts that the
British used to maintain their control of Iraq.
Rosen clearly has a very deep understanding of
the ethnic undercurrents of Iraq and how they led to the extremely brutal civil
conflict that the American forces and their allies tried to tamp down. This
book is a demonstration of how ignorant of the American body politic is of the internal
structure of other nations.
The war in Afghanistan is also covered, but
not to the amount of ink expended on Iraq. Clearly, Rosen is also very knowledgeable
about this country as well. Once again there is a demonstration of how ignorant
the American body politic is about Afghanistan. The rather ignominious
departure of the American military was predictable, given how the Afghans were able
to deal with their British and Soviet invaders.
It is not possible for me to understate the
significance of this book as the United States continues to engage in acts of
war against the Muslim world. None of the recent US military interventions in
Muslim countries have had an outcome anywhere near what the stated intentions
were.